Forum Topic

It is bizarre (if hardly surprising) that Sunak has picked on this 'issue'.The Environment act 2021 (written by the government, though admittedly probably under May and Johnson and heaven knows how many environment ministers, says quite clearly (section 57):"Recyclable household waste must be collected as individual streams unless the exceptions in the new Section 45A(6) EPA [which relates to remote geographies]  1990 apply. To rely on these exceptions, a Waste Collection Agency must provide a written assessment stating it considers that separate collection:Would not be technically or economically practicable; orHas no significant environmental benefitIn any case, dry recyclable waste streams must never be mixed with food or garden waste streams.Food waste collection must take place at least once a week"The main discussion about the Environment Act was whether councils which collect 'mixed dry waste' would be allowed to continue collect mixed waste on the footpath and manually sort it when it got to a waste site. The consensus was that they would not be allowed to do this but the government have not made their mind up (they only had several years thinking about it and consulting and two years since they passed the Act). Hounslow decided not to do this several years ago, because it is costly to have council employees doing it and the quality of material sent for recycling is poor purity, and recyclers don't like it. Some of course mixed recycling ends up in a sea somewhere. Hounslow recycling never does.We had a lot of grief when we started this system but I haven't had a single complaint about multiple boxes since I have been cabinet member for the last 5 years.Most houses (and estates) in Hounslow have 1 residual waste bin. three recycle boxes, one food waste bin. Many people optionally subscribe to garden waste collection at a current cost of £65 per year for about 25 collections. People obviously think this is well worth it because the number of subscribers increases every year.So all of that means 6 boxes, and we also collect some other stuff in bags (textiles and shoes, small electrical items) but these don't involve a seventh bin, though people who know about it are grateful we offer it, as do those who use the bulky waste service - much more economical than commercial offers. It's obvious why Sunak is now coming out complaining about his own parliament policy. He's desperate to find a reason to vote Conservative because most people have realised there are no other reasons. He's following Cameron into the 'Green crud' cul de sac. It is unlikely to end well. A poll published today said the popularity of the conservatives amongst 18-24 year old voters was 1% (labour was 60-something percent)

Guy Lambert ● 1084d

Great to hear from a couple of enthusiasts who are doing their best to do the right thing.The truth about recycling is that it is full of compromises and professionals have to make judgments based on the best compromise to encourage. Tetrapaks are a good example: I looked at a couple of years ago, when I was told there were at least 4 different components in a Tetrapak - cardboard, polythene lining, aluminium (not sure why) and plastic caps etc.It is impossible to strip each element, except in one place in the UK, but using it is wildly uneconomic given that a Local Authority gets a very limited quantity (always decreasing - rarely now for milk, juice, soup). The vast majority is cardboard, and cardboard recyclers are happy to take them, so that's what we do - put it with the other cardboard.Haven't been to a cardboard recycler (they are overseas) but I have been to Mitcham https://www.biocollectors.com/ to look at food recycling. Most of the stuff is either 'loose' or in biodegradable bags. But some people use ordinary bags and the recyclers have to sort them using a hideous conveyor belt. This happens after a first session of decaying in a tank. They fish out the real plastic and dispose of it, but they get the biodegradable bags and send them back to the tank. It takes up to 4 dips before they are sufficiently degraded to go into their anaerobic digester (where the stuff is turned into gas for the network and fertiliser for farmers) It is true of other things you mentioned - windows or staples in cardboard or paper don't discourage recyclers - they love our stuff because it's relatively pure. If paper ends up in cardboard - no biggie but the price it earns is less. Too much cardboard in the paper could lead to a whole consignment being rejected. Very rare for us. As to education etc, we often put it into Hounslow Matters about once a year and often via messages on bins themselves or through doors. Latest campaign is https://www.hounslow.gov.uk/news/article/2826/no_time_to_waste_new_campaign_launches_in_hounslow_to_encourage_recyclingAs to government, you're right and there has been a lot of effort put in by DEFRA, councils, the industry etc and this resulted to the Environment Act 2021. A lot of it has not actually been finalised and Sunak putting his poorly thought through oar in will only delay it further and make it worse.

Guy Lambert ● 1081d