Forum Topic

My next car will definitely be an EV.  There are just so many myths about EVs1. Battery life is not an issue.  Average mileage per year in UK is roughly 7500 miles - current batteries will happily last for 150,000 miles and still deliver 70% of original capacity so that is more than 20 years of use - and the average UK car owner changes cars roughly every 6 years.2. Range is not an issue as long as you pick an EV which has a range equating to your use.  Do not complain about lack of range when you buy a car with a 150 mile range (urban cycle) and you regularly do a 200+ mile motorway trip.  The reality is that if the car has a range of more than 200 miles at motorway speeds, you ought to stop long before the battery dies.3. Charge times are also not a real issue.  You charge at night when you are asleep. Even in a petrol car when I stop at a motorway service station I am normally there for 30-40 minutes which is enough time to get a decent charge for an EV at worst I might have to wait an extra 15 minutes.4. We are not running out of lithium any time soon, American Geological survey estimated reserves of 85 million tonnes so in theory we could run out sometime towards the end of the century but that assumes no recycling of lithium (which will happen) and that technology improvements does not reduce the need for lithium.  Consider that over the last 10 years battery manufacturers have massively reduced the need for cobalt and it is clear that there is nothing to get worked up about.5. EVs do not emit copious amounts of brake dust.  Real world data from the US suggests that on averages brake pads on EVs last 5-10x longer than for petrol cars.6. Tyre particulates is interesting.  EVs currently do shed more particulates for the simple reason they are heavier than equivalent petrol car.  But a lot of that is due to how tyres are made, and that is the only particulate that EVs emit more of than a petrol car.But there are definite downsides to an EV - the charging infrastructure in the UK is a mess, not enough chargers, too many incompatible apps.  Govt regulation would help - for example requiring all public chargers to accept debit/credit cards.  EVs cost significantly more to buy than a petrol car although total cost of ownership is lower.  And of course owning an EV when you do not have access to charging over night is not great

Justin Stephenson ● 1089d

An EV can make financial sense, particularly as a company car (which of course helps only a minority of people).BIK (tax on "benefit in kind") for a comapny car EV is currently 1%.  Lease costs for an expensive company car (say a £70k Audi or Mercedes) are around £700 - £800 a month). But for an additional rate tax payer employee (45%) fund via salary sacrifice the true net cost ( loss of money in their pocket) is about 50% - so say £5,000 a year. Tax for BIK for an equivalent petrol or diesel car could be £10k a year.Either lease costs is a lot of money.  But then the savings: no toad tax: no London congestion charge; cost of fuel (if charged at home - for someone with a drive - currently 8p per kwh. Which works out at 2.5p per mile, so equivalent to 280 mpg.(But costs a lot more when fast charging at servive stations, but then again many supermarkets now have free charging). So 12k miles a year cost £300.  Compared with a petrol car doing say 30 mpg costs about £2,700. So, even taking into account some away from home charging, another £2k saving a year.Servicing costs are next to nil.So, like so many government policies- a lot of money to be saved if you can afford an expensive car.But the sums can also make sense for a personal lease. I've been looking at a Vauxhall Corse (which is essentially same car as the DS and Peugeot).  The electric version is around £255 a month. Non-electric about £50 a month less, but fuel saving on say 12,000 mile a year at least £100 a month.So it makes sense if (a) you want / can afford a new car: (b) do a lot of miles (or drive into the congestionzone): (c) and in particular havr home charging.As for the cars - I would never go back to a non-electric car. The good ones are, like for like, years ahead.Your fueling style has to change. Fortunately I have a home charger, so just plug the car in when I get home. But on long journeys one has to plan ahead. For example - driving to the South of France will take about 4 fueling stops - but the trick is to tie them in which coffee/ lunch breaks.  (Newer cars will do it in 2, but I  doubt many humans coudd drive 900 miles without at least three or four breaks).Fast charging is just as important as range. A car that can charge fast (100 kwh or even 350kwh) will add a few hundred miles in as long as it takes to get a quick cup of coffee.All in all, I spend far less time at fuel stations because I mostly change at hone.Personally, I would still lease rather than buy for the next year or so, because EVs are getting so much better so quickly (range, charging speed, costs etc.)

T P Howell ● 1090d