Forum Topic

Bruce, as it happens the interim assessment of the traffic schemes has just been published. The independent consultants, Steer, reported on traffic trends separately for three areas of Chiswick in Hounslow: north and south of the High Road and south of the A4. They used a mixture of traffic counts and GPS data and compared four weeks in Jan-Feb with four weeks in Oct-Sep, so before all of the South Chiswick restrictions came in.Here is their summary:_______________There appears to have been a reduction in the number of local trips using roads in the area north of Chiswick High Road that is more significant than the borough-wide trend. End to end trips have become more direct within the area north of Chiswick High Road, this is especially apparent for local trips.There has been a significant decrease in the number of local vehicle trips using roads in the area south of Chiswick High Road, which is bigger than the fall in through trips. Average end-to-end trip speeds for local trips using roads in the area south of Chiswick High Road appear to have increased more than the borough-wide average. Similarly, local trips using roads in the area appear to have become slightly more direct on average.Traffic flows on Wellesley Road, Stile Hill Gardens and Harvard Hill have been significantly reduced due to the introduction of the schemes. In the area around Wellesley Road, there has been a very large drop in the number of through trips using these roads. In the area around Harvard Hill the drop in through trips is exceeded by the drop in local trips. Thames Road and Strand-on-the-Green have experienced a significant increase in vehicle flows which may be partially linked to the Harvard Hill scheme causing traffic to find alternative routes. Generally, trips using roads in the area have become less direct, except for local trips using roads in the area near Harvard Hill. Traffic on Dan Mason Drive has significant reduced, with a smaller decrease also seen on The Promenade. It does not appear that nearby roads have seen increases in flows due to displaced traffic._________So in short, except for in Strand on the Green, the number of trips in Chiswick has reduced beyond that seen in the rest of the borough, and those trips have on the whole become more direct.https://lbhounslow.sharepoint.com/:b:/s/InternetLinks/cc/EWFs8hGab6RDjECqo-0DKaUB7DenZFY127MUQiUO1zTKOQ?e=Dc38Ay

Tom Pike ● 1988d

Tom, thanks for that. I'm not entirely sure what I'm supposed to glean from the information - which may be down to my lack of familiarity with these sorts of data. I dislike using personal anecdote and I know you have no time for it, but sometimes it's all the average person has to call on.Therefore I can only tell you that my experience of using buses in and around Chiswick High Road since the introduction of LTNs and C9 is that bus journeys are longer and certainly much more unpredictable in duration than previously. My most frequent route is from Grove Park, across the A4 then either directly onwards along the High Road or down Acton Lane and South Parade. The buses involved are on routes E3 272 and 94. Since these journeys are mostly for medical appointments I can't be late, so now I have to factor in the possibility that not infrequently I may have to abandon the bus and walk. The irony is that I often used to do this journey  by bicycle, but I find the Cycleway very unpleasant to use, and frankly I don't want to be seen to be endorsing something so ill-considered and unfair to so many people. Of course I know that's not your view of it. If I do cycle I now use the paths along the A4 - again I don't want to resurrect ancient history! Let us never forget that all these measures were brought in to mitigate the effects of the pandemic and for no other reason. Only when the pandemic is properly over can we discuss a properly thought-through and inclusive strategy to address pollution, roads and investment in transport of all kinds.

Bruce Hammal ● 1988d