Forum Topic

Tom there are massive flaws in the reasoning on Staveley Road.There was unquestionably an issue with non-local traffic (I will come back to the issue of what is local and non-local) come from the A316 up Staveley Road to SCR and then on to the A4, or carrying on up SCR to Acton, Ealing etc.  The solution to that should have to ban the turn from the A316 onto Staveley Road. That would have solved the problem completely.  So the question then becomes why was it not adopted?I am less convinced that there was an issue with vehicles travelling from SCR down Staveley Road to A316 but as LBH figures did not break down the direction of vehicle journeys down Staveley Road it is impossible to be sure.  Ideally what we would need is information about number of vehicles, the type of vehicles, where they are coming from and where they were going to in order to make a full assessment of the scale of the problem and what the effects of different solutions would be.Because we do not have that information we do not know if journeys down Staveley Road from SCR to A316 are a problem, nor do we know what the effects of the temporary barrier are.  However we can come to some conclusions based on anecdotal evidence (not great but we have to work with what we have).1. It is probably that there are relatively few journeys involving cars coming east on A4 using Staveley Road as a cut through because the route turning left off the A4 at the Porsche Garage, right onto Barrowgate Road and right onto SCR, waiting at the SCR/A4 lights and then going over the A4 down SCR is a lot more time consuming and cumbersome than simply continuing down the A4 to Hogarth's roundabout and turning onto the A316 there.2. Because Hartingon Road will be closed to vehicles turning north off the A316 it is likely that more vehicles will turn north onto Staveley Road (at least outside of the designated school hours) and then turn left onto Burlington Lane to get to the SCR.3. The opposite is likely to happen for vehicle travelling south from A4/SCR.  Because they will no longer be able to use Staveley Road as a cut through they will go over the railway bridge onto Hartington Road to get to the SCRI can see why such a solution might look initially attractive to a town planner - they have created a sort of one way system for vehicles that want to go from A316 to A4 or vice versa: you use SCR/Hartington Road if travelling south to A316 and Staveley Road/SCR if travelling north from A316.  The problem is the obvious pinch points at the railway bridge, the traffic calming on Hartington Road, the fact that Staveley Road by the school is, due to cars and coaches parking, very narrow and effectively single lane and the area around the train station becoming a potential accident blackspot due to the increased traffic.Then there is the issue that non of the schemes truly try to distinguish Chiswick resident local traffic from non-local traffic.  The way LBH have set up the schemes implies that residents of Chiswick who are north of the A4 are not "local traffic".  It seems LBH is deliberately trying to break up Chiswick as a single community - why?

Justin Stephenson ● 2158d